demographicsbyebyelove

byebyelove  时间:2021-01-12  阅读:()
Psychologists'UseofMotionPicturesinClinicalPracticeGeorgiosK.
LampropoulosBallStateUniversityNikolaosKazantzisMasseyUniversityandWaitemataDistrictHealthBoardCognitiveTherapyCenterFrankP.
DeaneUniversityofWollongongDoprofessionalpsychologistsusemotionpicturesinclinicalpracticeIfso,dotheyconsidermotionpicturestohavetherapeuticvalueOf827licensedpracticingpsychologists,67%reportedtheuseofmotionpicturestopromotetherapygains.
Mostofthesepractitioners(88%)consideredtheuseofmotionpicturesaseffectiveinpromotingtreatmentoutcome,andonlyaminority(1%)reportedthemaspotentiallyharmful.
Comparedwiththeirpsychodynamiccounterparts,therapistspracticingwithineclectic–integrative,cognitive–behavioral,orhumanisticframeworksweremorelikelytovieworusemotionpicturesastherapeutictools.
Psychologistsprovidedindividualevaluationsof27motionpicturesthatdealwithavarietyofmentalhealthsubjects,andoveralltheywerecharacterizedas"moderatelyhelpful.
"Clinicalapplicationsandissuespertainingtousingmotionpicturesintherapyaresummarized.
Thereisincreasinginterestintheuseofself-helpmaterials,butrelativelylittleisknownaboutpsychologists'actualuseofself-helpmaterialsinclinicalpractice.
Recentadvancesinself-helpmaterials(booksandself-helpgroups)includetheuseofcinema-therapyorvideowork,thatis,theuseofentertainmentmotionpicturesfortherapeuticpurposes(Berg-Cross,Jennings,&Baruch,1990;Hesley&Hesley,1998;Solomon,1995;Sharp,Smith,&Cole,2002).
Motionpicturesholdseveraladvantagesoverotherself-helpmaterialsbecausetheyaretypicallymoreavailable,fa-miliar,andaccessible,andtheyoftenrepresenteasy,quick,andpleasurableactivitiesforclients(Hesley&Hesley,1998).
How-ever,thereislittleinformationontheextenttowhichthegeneralpsychologistpopulationusesmotionpicturesinclinicalpracticeandonwhichmotionpicturesareconsideredtohavetherapeuticvalue.
Theuseofmotionpicturesintherapymayalsovaryasafunctionofpractitioners'clinicalexperience,theoreticalorienta-tion,worksetting,andotherpracticecharacteristics.
Thepresentstudywasdesignedtoprovidedataonusingmotionpicturesinclinicalpractice.
Inthelate1970sRheaRubinprovidedadetailedaccountoftherationaleandbenefitsfortheclinicaluseoftheself-helpmaterials,suchaspsychologicalbooks,poetry,andliterature(Rubin,1978a,1978b).
Therangeoftherapeuticself-helpmaterialshassinceexpandedtoincludeclientautobiographies,theInternet,andmo-tionpictures(L'Abate,2004;Norcross,2000;Scogin,2003a).
Delphipollsofpsychotherapyexpertspredictedthatself-helpandself-changewouldbeamongtheclinicalinterventionsofthefuture(Norcross,Alford,&DeMichele,1992;Norcross,Hedges,&Prochaska,2002).
Thisexpansionissupportedbyavarietyofsocioeconomicandclinicalfactors(Norcross,2000),includingthestudyofclientself-changewithinandoutsidetherapy(Bohart&Tallman,1999;Prochaska&DiClemente,1992).
Motionpicturesarenotonlynarrativesthattransmitthevaluesandideasofourculture,butalsoaverypopularandwidespreadmethodofcommunicationandexpression.
Intreatment,moviescanbeseenastherapeuticmetaphorsthatcanintroduceclientstomaterialthatissensitiveorperceivedasthreatening(Hesley&Hesley,1998;Heston&Kottman,1997).
Moviecharacterscanessentiallyactascotherapistsforclients.
Inaddition,HesleyandHesley(1998)describedhowtherapistsusemotionpicturestopromotetherapeuticchangebyofferinghopeandencouragement,GEORGIOSK.
LAMPROPOULOSreceivedhisMAinclinicalpsychologyfromtheUniversityofCrete,Greece.
HeisadoctoralstudentincounselingpsychologyatBallStateUniversity,Muncie,Indiana,andascholarshiprecipientoftheAlexanderS.
OnassisPublicBenefitFoundation,Athens,Greece.
HeisalsoaninternattheCentreforAddictionandMentalHealth,MoodandAnxietyProgram,Toronto,Ontario,Canada.
Hisresearchinterestsincludepsychotherapyprocessandoutcomeresearch,psychother-apyintegration,self-help,andpsychotherapytraining.
NIKOLAOSKAZANTZISreceivedhisPhDinpsychologyfromMasseyUni-versity,NewZealand,wherehecurrentlyholdsanappointmentasalecturer(equivalentassistantprofessor).
HeisalsoaclinicalpsychologistandcoordinatorofresearchattheWaitemataDistrictHealthBoardCog-nitiveTherapyCenter.
Hisresearchprogramisfocusedontheroleoftherapeutichomeworkassignmentsincognitive–behavioraltherapy.
FRANKP.
DEANEreceivedhisPhDinpsychologyfromMasseyUniversity,NewZealand.
HeisaprofessorinpsychologyanddirectoroftheIllawarraInstituteforMentalHealthattheUniversityofWollongong,Australia.
Hisresearchinterestsincludehelpseekingformentalhealthproblems,useofhomeworkinpsychosocialinterventions,treatmentadherence,andrecov-eryprocessesforrecurringmentalillness.
THISRESEARCHISSUPPORTEDinpartbyGrant1157553216andMasseyUniversityResearchAwardPR56786.
1207MURF,agrantfromtheIlla-warraInstituteforMentalHealth,UniversityofWollongong,andagrantfromtheLyellBussellMemorialGraduateFund,BallStateUniversity.
CORRESPONDENCECONCERNINGTHISARTICLEshouldbeaddressedtoGeor-giosK.
Lampropoulos,DepartmentofCounselingPsychology,TC622,BallStateUniversity,Muncie,IN47306.
E-mail:g_lamp@hotmail.
comProfessionalPsychology:ResearchandPracticeCopyright2004bytheAmericanPsychologicalAssociation2004,Vol.
35,No.
5,535–5410735-7028/04/$12.
00DOI:10.
1037/0735-7028.
35.
5.
535535deepeningemotion,providingrolemodels,enhancingclientstrengths,reframingproblems,improvingcommunication,andreprioritizingvalues.
Tothesecanbeaddedthepotentialbenefitsofprovidingclientswithsupportandacceptancefortheircondi-tionandfacilitatingemotionalrelief,informationgathering,prob-lemawareness,andpreparationforaction.
Forexample,thede-pictionofthestruggletoovercomealcoholisminarelationshipinWhenaManLovesaWoman(Kerner,Avnet,&Mandoki,1994)andtheimportanceofachild'swelfareinacustodybattleinKramervs.
Kramer(Jaffe&Benton,1979)aretwowell-knownmotionpicturesthataddressimportantclinicalissues.
Indeed,thereisavastarrayofmotionpicturesthatdealwithabandonment,abuse,adoption,alcoholanddruguse,deathanddying,divorce,adolescence,family,vocation,friendship,gambling,eatingprob-lems,mentalillness,physicalillness,andsexuality.
Thesemate-rialshavebeensupportedbyanincreasingnumberofpractitionerrecommendationsonhowtousetheminclinicalpractice(seeDermer&Hutchings,2000;Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Norcrossetal.
,2000,2003;Solomon,1995,2001).
Evidencefromexperimentalresearchhassupportedtheasser-tionthatself-helpmaterialscanenhancetherapeuticeffectiveness.
Meta-analyticreviewshavedemonstratedthatcertainself-helpprogramsaresuperiortoplaceboandevenequallyeffectivewiththerapist-facilitatedinterventionsforavarietyofpsychologicalproblems(Cuijpers,1997;Gould&Clum,1993;Marrs,1995;Scogin,2003b;Scogin,Bynum,Stephens,&Calhoon,1990).
However,fewstudieshaveassessedtheextenttowhichself-helpmaterialsareusedinclinicalpractice.
Surveysofpractitioners'useofself-helpbooksandclientautobiographieshaveshownthatasubstantialpercentageofclinicianshaveusedthemfortherapeuticpurposes(Clifford,Norcross,&Sommer,1999;Marx,Royalty,Gyorky,&Stern,1992;Norcrossetal.
,2000,2003;Starker,1988).
Norcrossetal.
(2000)providedpreliminarydataontheclinicaluseofmoviesfrom401membersoftheclinicalandcounselingpsychologydivisionsoftheAmericanPsychologicalAssociation(APA).
Theresearchersreportedthatalmostonehalfofrespon-dentsrecommendedmoviestotheirclientsandthat68%ofthesepractitionersfoundthemhelpful(2%perceivedthemasharmful).
Norcrossetal.
alsoobtainedqualityratingsforalistofmotionpicturesacross20problemareas,whichtheyhavesinceupdatedwiththeevaluationsofadditionaltitlesfromasubsequentsurveyof316clinicalandcounselingpsychologists(Norcrossetal.
,2003).
Despitetheseemergingdataonpractice,therearenopublishedreportsaboutthemethodsofmotionpictureuse,orwhetherpractitionerswithdifferentlevelsofexperience,theoret-icalorientation,worksetting,andothercharacteristicsdifferintheirclinicaluseofmotionpictures.
Similarly,therearenopub-lishedreportsonthespecificmotionpicturesmostcommonlyrecommendedtoclients.
ThisprojectprovidessuchinformationbysurveyingasampleofAPApractitioners.
1TheMoviesProjectConsistentwithpriorsurveysofpsychologists'useandevalu-ationofself-helpbooksandautobiographiesformentalhealthclients(Cliffordetal.
,1999;Marxetal.
,1992;Starker,1988),weaimedtoprovidepreliminarydatathatcouldassistpractitionersinevaluatingandusingpopularentertainmentmotionpicturesintherapy.
DopsychologistsbelievethatmotionpicturescanbetherapeuticandusedintreatmentHavetheyeverdiscussedorrecommendedamovietoaclientIfso,inwhatwayhavetheyuseditinsessionandwhatweretheresultsAretheyfamiliarwithsomeofthecommonlyusedmotionpicturesinclinicalpractice,andwouldtheyrecommendthemtootherpractitionersThepresentstudyobtainedinformationondemographics,the-oreticalorientation,attitudes,evaluation,patternsofclinicaluseofmotionpictures,andratingsofspecificmotionpictures.
Thelatterlistwasdevelopedonthebasisofthelistsofmotionpicturesdescribedinthetwomajorguidebooksoncinematherapy(Hesley&Hesley;1998;Solomon,1995),fromwhichwechoseonlythosetitlesthatwerealsorecommendedbythementalhealthprofes-sionalsinasmalllocalsurveybyDermerandHutchings(2000).
Thisprocedurewasusedtoensuretitlerecognitionandclinicaluseofmotionpicturesinoursurvey.
Thefinallistcomprised27titlesthatcoveredavarietyofproblemsanddisorders.
InSeptember2000,acoverletter,thesurvey,andapostage-paidreturnenvelopeweremailedto3,000randomlyselectedmembersoftheAPA.
ThemailinglabelswereprovidedbytheAPAwiththeconstraintsthatpsychologists(a)residedintheUnitedStates,(b)werelicensedpractitioners,and(c)hadindicatedthattheprovisionofhealthandmentalhealthserviceswastheirprimaryactivityintheirprimaryorsecondaryworksetting.
Twoweekslaterare-mindercardwassenttoallparticipants,and1monthlaterasecondsurveywasmailedto1,200randomlyselectedparticipantsfromtheoriginal3,000.
Thereturnrateof28%yielded840returnsandatotalof827usablereturns.
Allresponseswerecompletelyanonymous.
Thereturnenvelopeswerenotcodedandwerede-stroyedonreceipt.
Toevaluatetherepresentativenessoftherespondents,wecom-paredtheircharacteristicswiththoseoftheinitialsampleof3,000providedbytheAPA,aswellasthoseoftheAPAmemberswhoprovidementalhealthservices(providedbytheAPAresearchdepartment).
Therespondentshadalmostidenticalcharacteristicswithbothofthesegroupsintermsofgender,age,race–ethnicity,highestdegreeobtained,numberofyearssincedegree,andareaofhighestacademicqualification.
Forty-ninepercentofrespondentsweremenand95%ofrespondentswereCaucasian.
Themeanageofrespondentswas52.
43years(SD9.
64).
Intermsofprofes-sionaldegree,84%hadearnedaPhD,9%hadearnedaPsyD,4%hadearnedanEdD,and3%hadearnedanotheradvanceddegree.
Respondentshadbeenoutofgraduateschoolanaverageof18.
60years(SD9.
51).
Seventy-sixpercentofrespondentsidentifiedwithclinicalpsychology,18%withcounselingpsychology,2%withschoolpsychology,and4%with"other.
"Althoughthesam-plehadsimilarcharacteristicstotheinitialAPA-providedsampleandwassimilartorecentpractitionersurveys(i.
e.
,30%inAddis&Krasnow,2000),thefinalresponserateof28%doessuggestthatthefindingsshouldbeconsideredindicativeandpreliminary.
Seventy-fourpercentofrespondentsreportedindependentprac-ticeastheirprimaryemploymentsetting,and94%ofrespondentsindicateddirectpatientcontactastheirprimaryprofessionalac-tivity.
Themeanpercentageofrespondents'annualcaseloadseenindifferenttherapyformatswas72%(SD19%)forindividual1TheresultsoftheNorcrossetal.
(2000)studywerenotavailableatthetimewewereplanningandconductingthedatacollectionforthisproject.
536LAMPROPOULOS,KAZANTZIS,ANDDEANEtherapy,16%(SD12%)forcouplestherapy,14%(SD15%)forfamilytherapy,and10%(SD14%)forgrouptherapy.
Respondentsreportedtreatingmostlyadults(68%ofyearlycase-load;SD25%),followedbyadolescents(17%;SD15%),children(17%;SD18%),olderadults(12%;SD12%),andinfants(1%;SD4%).
Intermsofprimarytheoreticalorienta-tion,respondentsself-identifiedwithcognitive–behavioraltherapy(41%),psychodynamic–analytictherapy(25%),existential–humanistictherapy(8%),interpersonaltherapy(8%),familysys-temstherapy(4%),behavioraltherapy(2%),sociallearningther-apy(1%),andothertherapies(integrative–eclectic;12%).
TherangesandpercentagesoftheoreticalorientationswereconsistentwithasurveyofAPADivision12(ClinicalPsychology)members(Norcross,Karg,&Prochaska,1997).
AttitudesandUseofMotionPicturesinClinicalPracticeSixty-sevenpercentofrespondingpracticingpsychologistsei-theragreed(54%)orstronglyagreed(13%)that"qualityenter-tainmentmotionpicturesthatdealwithpsychologicalissuescanbebeneficialandcouldbeusedfortherapeuticpurposes(e.
g.
,awarenessraising,modelingbehavior,andclientinspiration).
"Twenty-fivepercentofrespondentsremainedneutral,andonly8%ofrespondentsindicatedtheyeitherdisagreedorstronglydis-agreedwiththeabovestatement(Mresponse3.
67,SD0.
90,onaLikert-typescalewithanchors1stronglydisagreeand5stronglyagree).
Wewereinterestedinexaminingwhethertheoreticalorientationwasrelatedtotheperceivedtherapeuticvalueofmotionpicturesfortworeasons.
First,assigningmotionpicturesintherapyhasbeendescribedasatypeofhomeworkassignment(Hesley&Hesley,1998),andhomeworkhasbeentraditionallyassociatedwiththepracticeofcognitive–behavioraltherapycomparedwithothertherapies(Blagys&Hilsenroth,2002;Kazantzis&Deane,1999).
Second,theuseofmotionpicturesasself-helpadjunctstotherapyisconsistentwiththetenetsofhumanistictherapy,whereclientsareseenasactiveself-healers(Bohart&Talman,1999).
Therefore,werecodedtheoreticalorientationintofivecategories(cognitive–behavioral,humanistic–existential,psychodynamic–analytic,interpersonal–familysystems,andeclectic–integrative)andconductedananalysisofvariance(ANOVA)toexaminedifferencesamongpractitionersofmajortheoreticalorientations.
Forthepotentialvalueofusingmotionpicturesintherapy,therewerestatisticallysignificantdifferencesamongrespondentsofdifferenttheoreticalorientations,F(4,760)4.
70,p.
001.
ATukeyposthoctestrevealedthatcognitive–behavioral(M3.
76,SD0.
87)andeclectic–integrative(M3.
81,SD0.
77)therapistsmorefrequentlyconsideredmotionpicturesastherapeu-tictoolsthandidpsychodynamic–analytictherapists(M3.
44,SD0.
95),p.
01.
Whenaskedaboutthenaturaloccurrenceofin-sessiondiscus-sionsofmotionpictures,90%ofrespondentsreportedthattheyhaddiscussedamotionpicturewithaclientintherapywithoutnecessarilyrecommendingit.
Sixty-sevenpercentofrespondentsreportedthattheyhadrecommendedamotionpicturetoaclient,asubstantiallyhigherproportionthanthe46%reportedintheNorcrossetal.
(2000)study.
Practitionerswhohadrecommendedamotionpicturetoaclientwereaskedtocheckuptofouroptionsdescribingthemethodtheyusedforincorporatingmotionpicturesintherapy.
Ofthe536respondentswhorecommendedamotionpicturetoaclient,95%discussedthemovieinsession,53%recommendedthemoviebutdidnotdiscussitinsession,29%assignedtherapeutichomeworkrelatedtothemovie,and5%watchedthemovieorpartsofitwiththeclientinsession.
Thepercentagesreportedfortheuseofeachmethodwerecomparablewiththosereportedforself-helpbooks(Marxetal.
,1992)andautobiographiesofmentalhealthclients(Cliffordetal.
,1999),suggestingthatthein-sessionuseofmotionpicturesmaybesimilartootheradjunctiveself-helpmaterials.
Achi-squareanalysisrevealedsignificantdifferencesamongpractitionersofmajortheoreticalorientationsintheiruseofmo-tionpictures,2(4,N772)35.
48,p.
001.
Morespecifically,87%ofeclectic–integrativepractitionershadrecommendedmo-tionpicturesasatherapyadjunct,whereas79%ofhumanistic–existentialpractitioners,65%ofinterpersonal–systemicpractitio-ners,65%ofcognitive–behavioralpractitioners,and54%ofpsychodynamic–analyticpractitionershadrecommendedmotionpictures.
Additionalchi-squaretestsbetweenpairsoftheoreticalorientationswereconducted,withalphasetatp.
01foralltests(toreducethelikelihoodofTypeIerror).
Thesetestsrevealedthat(a)eclectic–integrativetherapistsweremorelikelytorecommendmoviescomparedwithpractitionerswithinterpersonal,cognitive–behavioral,andpsychodynamicorientations,and(b)humanistic–existentialtherapistsweremorelikelytorecommendmoviesthantheirpsychodynamic–analyticcolleagues.
Statisticaltestswerealsoconductedtoexaminedifferencesinuseofmotionpicturesintermsofthefollowingfivevariablesofinterest:practitioners'gender,clinicalexperience,primaryem-ploymentsetting(privatepracticevs.
other),typeofacademicdegree(PhDvs.
PsyD),andareaofacademicdegree(clinicalvs.
counselingpsychology).
Malerespondentswereslightlymorelikelytohaverecommendedamovietoaclientthanwomen(72%vs.
60%),2(2,N802)12.
34,p.
001.
Psychologistsinprivatepracticewerealsomorelikelytohaverecommendedamovietoaclientcomparedwiththosewhoreportedadifferentprimaryemploymentsetting(70%vs.
58%),2(2,N791)10.
12,p.
001.
Intermsofclinicalexperience,psychologistswhohadrecommendedamotionpicturetoaclienthadmoreyearsofclinicalpractice(M21.
41,SD9.
08)thantheircolleagueswhohadneverrecommendedamovie(M19.
01,SD8.
70),t(797)3.
58,p.
001.
However,theuseofmotionpictureswasnotsignificantlydifferentamongthosewhowerePhDversusPsyDtrainedorbetweenthosetrainedinclinicalorcounselingdisciplines.
Tosurveytheperceivedtherapeuticeffectsofmotionpicturesasatherapyadjunct,weaskedpsychologiststoevaluatetheirownexperiencewithusingmotionpicturesintreatmentonaLikert-typescalewithanchorsof1(veryharmful)to5(veryhelpful).
Seventy-sixpercentofrespondentsratedtheeffectsassomewhathelpfulandanadditional12%asveryhelpful,whereas11%didnotperceiveanyeffectsandonly1%ratedthemassomewhatharmful(andnoneratedthemasveryharmful).
RatingsofTherapeuticValueforSpecificMotionPicturesWiththegoalofprovidingpreliminarydataforpractitionersregardingtheperceivedvalueofrecommendingparticularmotionpicturesintreatment,weprovidedparticipantswiththelistof27537PSYCHOLOGISTS'USEOFMOTIONPICTURESmotionpictures.
Table1presentsmotionpictures'titles,yearsofrelease,andmainpsychological–therapeuticsubjects.
Thelatterissuewasnotalwaysclear-cutbecausemostofthesemotionpicturesdealtwithavarietyofsubjects,anddescriptionswerebasedonareviewofdifferentsources(i.
e.
,Dermer&Hutchings,2000;Hesley&Hesley;1998;Solomon,1995).
Participantswhorecommendmotionpictures(n536)indi-catedwhethertheyhadseeneachmovie,withresponsesrangingfrom27(5%)to501(93%)respondentsforthemostpopularmovie(seeTable1).
Thetherapeuticqualityofeachmoviefortreatmentpurposeswasthenratedonthefollowingscale:–2extremelybad(thismovieexemplifiedtheworstofthesetypeofmotionpictures);–1moderatelybad(notagoodmovie,mayprovidemisleadingorinaccurateinformation);0neutral(anaveragemovieofthistype);1moderatelygood(providesgoodinsight,canbehelpful);2extremelygood(outstanding,highlyrecommended).
Thisscalewasbasedonthoseusedinsimilarstudiesofself-helpbooks(Santrock,Minnett,&Campbell,1994)andmentalhealthclientautobiographies(Cliffordetal.
,1999).
Table1presentsthemeansandstandarddeviationsoftherapeu-ticqualityratingsforthe27movietitles.
Movieratingsrangedfrom0.
29to1.
33forthemostvaluablemotionpictures,whicharepresentedinrankedorder.
Overall,thesespecificmotionpictureswereconsideredtobemoderatelyhelpful,andnoneofthemreceivednegativemeanratings.
Practitionerswerealsogiventheoptiontociteandevaluatetheirownmotionpicturesattheendofourpreparedlist,inaresponsechoicemarkedas"other.
"Respondentswhorecommendmotionpictures(n536)alsoindicatedwhichofthelistedmotionpicturestheyhadrecom-mendedtoaclient,withthenumberoftherapistshavingrecom-mendedeachtitlerangingfrom3to188(seeTable1).
Asaseconddescriptiveanalysisofthesedata,thepercentageofthesamplethathadviewedandsubsequentlyusedamovieintherapycanbeusedtoindicatehow"recommended"amoviemightbe.
ThehighestpercentagewasforOrdinaryPeople(41%ofthesamplewhoviewedituseditintherapy),whichalsoreceivedthehighestqualityrating.
Theproportionoftherapistsusinganyspecificmovierangedbetween41%and11%.
Someinfrequentlyseenmotionpicturesmaybeusedrelativelyfrequentlybythesmallnumberoftherapistswhohaveseenthem(e.
g.
,UndertheInflu-ence,19of71,or27%,usedit).
Thesedatamayprovideprelim-inaryguidelinestohelpcliniciansselectandassessthetherapeuticqualityofspecificmotionpictures.
SummaryandImplicationsforPracticeOurstudyattemptedtoclarifyclinicians'attitudesandpatternsofuseofmotionpicturesfortherapeuticpurposesandprovideTable1FrequencyofRespondents(n536)WhoPersonallyViewedandTherapeuticallyUsedMotionPicturesandMeanRatingsofTheirTherapeuticQualityMotionpicture(yearandmainsubject)ViewedUsedTherapeuticqualitynn/%MSDnRankOrdinaryPeople(Schwary&Redford,1980;multigenerationalissues,loss)453188/411.
330.
724121Philadelphia(Saxon&Demme,1993;AIDSandprejudice)34268/201.
170.
803072TheGreatSantini(Pratt&Carlino,1979;father–sonrelationship,abuse)25289/351.
140.
852273OnGoldenPond(Gilbert&Rydell,1981;agingandrelationships)471126/271.
140.
764224TriptoBountiful(Vanwagenen,Forte,&Masterson,1985;ageandageism)19840/200.
970.
771795MyLife(Lowry&Rubin,1993;terminalillnessanddying)8421/250.
940.
85836Kramervs.
Kramer(R.
C.
Jaffe&Benton,1979;divorceandcustody)46297/210.
930.
814097Dad(Kennedy,Marshall,Spielberg,&Goldberg,1989;agingandfamily)7815/190.
910.
64758DeadPoetsSociety(Haft,Witt,Thomas,&Weir,1989;adolescence,familyissues)453105/230.
850.
764029WhenaManLovesaWoman(Kerner,Avnet,&Mandoki,1994;alcoholism)18447/260.
840.
8917010TermsofEndearment(Brooks,1983;terminalillness)43677/180.
840.
8538411Parenthood(Grazer&Howard,1989;parent–childrelationships)19244/230.
780.
8217212SteelMagnolias(Stark&Ross,1989;friendship,grief)38180/210.
770.
8034213OneFlewOvertheCuckoo'sNest(Douglas,Zaentz,&Forman,1975;mentalhealth)501116/230.
761.
0444714TheAccused(S.
R.
Jaffe,Lansing,&Kaplan,1988;sexualassault)15223/150.
760.
9513815UndertheInfluence(Greene&Carter,1986;alcoholisminthefamily)7119/270.
750.
777116It'saWonderfulLife(Capra,1946;meaninginlife,suicide)42277/180.
740.
8436817FourSeasons(Bregman&Alda,1981;divorceandremarriage)23234/150.
670.
7921218HowtoMakeanAmericanQuilt(Pilsbury,Sanford,&Moorhouse,1995;intimacy)13618/130.
670.
6112119LikeWaterforChocolate(Arau,1993;familyoforigin)28353/190.
640.
7825020ForestGump(Finerman,Starkey,Tisch,&Zemeckis,1994;mentalchallenges,labeling)47587/180.
640.
8642721TheBigChill(Kasdan,1983;friendship,grief)40052/130.
590.
7535622Nuts(Corman,Schwartz,Streisand,&Ritt,1987;sexualabuse)18634/180.
540.
9917423Bye,ByeLove(Goldberg,Hall,&Weisman,1995;divorce)273/110.
370.
792724DoloresClaiborne(Mulvehill&Hackford,1995;violenceandsexualabuse)15317/110.
340.
9114225WaroftheRoses(Brooks,Milchan,&DeVito,1989;conflictresolution)35265/180.
291.
1831526PrinceofTides(Karsch&Streisand,1991;sexualabuse)39782/210.
291.
3236227Note.
Viewednumberoftherapistswhoindicatedtheyhadpersonallyviewedthemovie.
Usednumberoftherapistswhoindicatedtheyhadusedthemoviefortherapeuticpurposeswithclients.
%usedpercentageoftherapistswhohadusedthemoviefromthosewhohadviewed.
Therapeuticqualityratingsofperceivedqualityofthemoviefortherapeuticpurposes(scalerangedfrom2extremelybadto2extremelygood).
538LAMPROPOULOS,KAZANTZIS,ANDDEANEpilotdataontheusefulnessofspecificmotionpicturesthatdealwithpsychologicalsubjects.
Overall,thefindingsareconsistentwiththoseofNorcrossetal.
(2000)inthatthemajorityofre-spondingpsychologistshaveatsomepointdiscussedamovieinsession,havepositiveattitudestowardmotionpictures,andusemotionpicturesinclinicalpractice.
Thesepreliminaryfindingsalsosuggestthatmotionpicturesarealmostaspopularandhelpfulasself-helpbooks,atleastaccordingtopractitioners'reports(seealsoNorcrossetal.
,2000).
However,ahigherpercentageofrespondentsinthepresentstudy(67%)hadrecommendedamo-tionpicturetoaclientthanintheNorcrossetal.
study(46%).
Consistentwiththis,88%inthepresentstudyconsideredtheuseofmotionpicturestobehelpfulintherapy,whereasalowerproportion(68%)ratedthemashelpfulintheNorcrossetal.
study.
ThesedifferencesmaybeduetooursamplehavingmoreprivatepractitionerscomparedwithNorcrossetal.
(74%and41%,re-spectively).
Privatepractitionersseemedtobemorewillingtorecommendmoviestotheirclients,aswasalsothecasewithself-helpbooks(seeMarxetal.
,1992).
Similartotheattitudestowardself-helpbooks(Campbell&Smith,2003),eclectic–integrative,cognitive–behavioral,andhumanistictherapistsweremorelikelytovieworusemotionpicturesastherapeutictoolscomparedwithpsychodynamic–analytictherapists.
Givensuchcommonuseandtheperceivedvalueofmotionpicturesintherapy,thereremainsaneedforresearchtoquantifytheeffectsonpsychotherapyprocessesandsubsequentoutcomes.
However,becauseitmaybeunrealistictoexpectthatspecificstudieswillbeconductedinthenearfutureforeachmotionpictureasatherapeutictool,ithasbeensuggestedthatpractitionerscouldexploretheclinicaluseoffilmsthathavealreadybeenpositivelyevaluatedandrecommendedbyhundredsoftherapists(Norcross,2003).
Theresultsofthepresentstudy,togetherwiththeNorcrossetal.
(2000,2003)studieshaveprovidedpreliminaryratingsontheperceivedvalueofseveralspecificmotionpicturesthatcoveravarietyofproblems.
Itisnotablethatthemajorityofthemotionpictureslistedinthisstudywereevaluatedpositivelybypractitio-nersinthepresentstudy.
Attheveryleast,thesefindingscanbeusedasapreliminaryclinicalresourceforselectingandusingmotionpicturesinclinicalpractice.
Althoughsomepractitionersdescribedtheuseofmotionpic-turesmorethanothers,ourdatasuggestthatpractitionersofalldifferentorientationsandtherapeuticmodalitieshaveusedthemasclinicaltools.
Practitioners'responsesincludedavarietyofin-sessionusesoffilms,fromsimplydiscussingafilminsession,toassigninghomeworkrelatedtoit,orevenwatchingpartsofitwiththeclient.
Motionpicturescanbeusefultherapyassignments,becausetheiraccessibility,familiarity,brevity,andentertainmentvaluecansparkclientcuriosity,buildtherapeuticrapport,andenhancehomeworkcompliance(Hesley&Hesley,2001).
How-ever,therapeuticviewingisdifferentfromentertainment,inthatitfocusesontheanalysisofmoviecharacters,theirrelationships,andbehaviorsandstrivesforclientinsightthroughconsciousidentificationwiththecharacters(Hesley&Hesley,2001).
Theevaluationsofmoviesprovidedbythepresentstudycanassistselection,butwealsorecommendconsultingotheravailablesourcestoobtainadditionalclinicalguidelineswithsuggestionsofspecificmoviesforspecificproblems(e.
g.
,Dermer&Hutchings,2000;Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Norcrossetal.
,2000,2003;Solomon,1995,2001).
Alternatively,interestedclinicianscanreadactualcasesofcinematherapy(e.
g.
,Heston&Kottman,1997;Wedding&Niemiec,2003)orevenanalysesofspecificmovietitlesfromdifferenttheoreticalorientations(e.
g.
,Cocks,1991;Paden-Levy,2000).
Thefollowingsummaryofgeneralrecommendationsandcau-tionsareofferedtoclinicianswhowanttointegratecinematherapyintotheirclinicalpractice.
1.
Therapistsshouldcarefullyconsiderwhoisandwhoisnotagoodcandidateforthetherapeuticuseofmotionpictures.
Someprerequisitesincludeatleastmoderateclientfunctioning,client'sinterestandenjoymentinwatchingmovies,andclient'sabilitytounderstandthemovie.
Theageoftheclient,degreeofimpairment,aswellasabilitytodistinguishbetweenfantasyandrealityareimportantconsiderations.
Inaddition,culturalanddisabilityissuesshouldbeconsidered,andspecialcautionisadvisedforclientswithseveretraumaorviolenceissues(Dermer&Hutchings,2000;Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Schulenberg,2003).
2.
Therapistsshouldchoosethetimingoftheinterventionandassignamoviethatisappropriateforclient'sproblems.
Moviesareusedastherapeutictoolsforspecificpurposesandshouldbewellintegratedinthetherapeuticprocess,caseformulation,andtreat-mentplan.
Usingonlyonemovieatatimeispreferredtomaxi-mizethebenefitoftheexperienceandnotoverwhelmtheclient(Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Solomon,1995;Sharpetal.
,2002;Schulenberg,2003).
3.
Movieselectioncriteriaincludechoosingtitlesthatclientsenjoyorarefamiliarwithandthoserecommendedbyotherther-apists.
Consideringaclient'sinputandbuildingonaclient'spreviousmovie-viewingexperiencemayalsoincreasecooperationwiththeassignmentandtheclient'sbenefitfromit(Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Schulenberg,2003).
4.
Desirablemoviecharacteristicsincludetheabilitytoinspireandevokeemotions,thedepictionofcharacterssolvingproblems,and,generally,ofappropriaterolemodels.
Itispreferablethatclientshavesimilardemographics,values,andlifestyleswithcharactersintheassignedmovies,sotheycanbetterrelate(Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Heston&Kottman,1997).
5.
Therapistsshouldviewamoviebeforeassigningittoaclientandhaveaclearrationalefordoingso.
Cliniciansshouldfirstnormalizetheexerciseandexplainittoclients.
Thisincludesexplainingexpectations,identifyingthecharacterstheclientshouldfocuson,andgivingspecificmovie-viewinginstructions(e.
g.
,watchfocused,pauseandreplayimportantscenes,keepnotesofinsightsandemotions,andpermissiontoturnthemovieoff).
Inaddition,therapistsshoulddiscussanyscenesthatmaybeoffensiveorproblematicaheadoftimeandaddressanyclientconcerns(Dermer&Hutchings,2000;Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Sharpetal.
,2002;Schulenberg,2003).
6.
Therapistsshouldprocesstheexerciseinadebriefingsessionandaddressanynegativeclientresponses.
Itisequallyimportanttoconsolidateclientinsightsandbenefitsfromwatchingthemovieaswellastoexamineandresolveanyfailedconnectionsoradverseeffects.
Last,therapistsshouldadaptandconnectthemovietotheclient'sreal-lifecontextandmakesuretheexerciseisintegratedintreatment(Dermer&Hutchings,2000;Hesley&Hesley,1998,2001;Heston&Kottman,1997;Solomon,1995;Sharpetal.
,2002;Schulenberg,2003).
Inconclusion,cliniciansareencouragedtoconsidermotionpicturesasanadjuncttoin-sessionorbetween-sessionsactivity.
539PSYCHOLOGISTS'USEOFMOTIONPICTURESInterestedpractitionersmayfindithelpfultofollowtheguidelinesforeffectivehomeworkassignments(seeKazantzis,Deane,Ro-nan,&L'Abate,inpress;Kazantzis&Lampropoulos,2002)aswellasthespecificrecommendationsforusingmotionpicturesintherapy(Hesley&Hesley,2001)tohelpclientsgaintherapeuticbenefitfromwatchingmovies.
Aspartofageneralscientist–practitionerapproachtoclinicalwork,wealsostronglyencouragepractitionerstoregularlymonitortheprocessandoutcomeoftheirclinicaluseofmotionpictures(seediscussionsinLambertetal.
,2003;Lampropoulosetal.
,2002).
ReferencesAddis,M.
E.
,&Krasnow,A.
D.
(2000).
Anationalsurveyofpracticingpsychologists'attitudestowardpsychotherapytreatmentmanuals.
Jour-nalofConsultingandClinicalPsychology,68,331–339.
Arau,A.
(Producer/Director).
(1993).
Likewaterforchocolate[Motionpicture].
Mexico:Cinevista.
Berg-Cross,L.
,Jennings,P.
,&Baruch,R.
(1990).
Cinematherapy:Theoryandapplication.
PsychotherapyinPrivatePractice,8,135–156.
Blagys,M.
D.
,&Hilsenroth,M.
J.
(2002).
Distinctivefeaturesofcognitive–behavioraltherapy:Areviewofthecomparativepsychother-apyprocessliterature.
ClinicalPsychologyReview,22,671–706.
Bohart,A.
,&Tallman,K.
(1999).
Howclientsmaketherapywork:Theprocessofactiveselfhealing.
Washington,DC:AmericanPsychologicalAssociation.
Bregman,M.
(Producer),&Alda,A.
(Director).
(1981).
Fourseasons[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:UniversalPictures.
Brooks,J.
L.
(Producer/Director).
(1983).
Termsofendearment[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ParamountPictures.
Brooks,J.
L.
,Milchan,A.
(Producers),&DeVito,D.
(Director).
(1989).
Waroftheroses[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:20thCenturyFox.
Campbell,L.
F.
,&Smith,T.
P.
(2003).
Integratingself-helpbooksintopsychotherapy.
JournalofClinicalPsychology,59,177–186.
Capra,F.
(Producer/Director).
(1946).
It'sawonderfullife[Motionpic-ture].
UnitedStates:RKORadioPictures.
Clifford,J.
S.
,Norcross,J.
C.
,&Sommer,R.
(1999).
Autobiographiesofmentalhealthclients:Psychologists'usesandrecommendations.
Pro-fessionalPsychology:ResearchandPractice,30,56–59.
Cocks,G.
(1991).
BringingtheHolocausthome:TheFreudiandynamicsofKubrick'sTheShining.
PsychoanalyticReview,78,103–125.
Corman,C.
,Schwartz,T.
,Streisand,B.
(Producers),&Ritt,M.
(Director).
(1987).
Nuts[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:WarnerBrothers.
Cuijpers,P.
(1997).
Bibliotherapyinunipolardepression:Ameta-analysis.
JournalofBehaviorTherapyandExperimentalPsychiatry,28,139–147.
Dermer,S.
B.
,&Hutchings,J.
B.
(2000).
Utilizingmoviesinfamilytherapy:Applicationsforindividuals,couples,andfamilies.
AmericanJournalofFamilyTherapy,28,163–180.
Douglas,M.
,Zaentz,S.
(Producers),&Forman,M.
(Director).
(1975).
Oneflewoverthecuckoo'snest[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:UnitedArtists.
Finerman,W.
,Starkey,S.
,Tisch,S.
(Producers),&Zemeckis,R.
(Direc-tor).
(1994).
ForestGump[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ParamountPictures.
Gilbert,B.
(Producer),&Rydell,M.
(Director).
(1981).
Ongoldenpond[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:UniversalPictures.
Goldberg,G.
D.
,Hall,B.
(Producers),&Weisman,S.
(Producer/Director).
(1995).
Bye,byelove[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:20thCenturyFox.
Gould,R.
A.
,&Clum,G.
A.
(1993).
Ameta-analysisofself-helptreatmentapproaches.
ClinicalPsychologyReview,13,169–186.
Grazer,B.
(Producer),&Howard,R.
(Director).
(1989).
Parenthood[Mo-tionpicture].
UnitedStates:UniversalPictures.
Greene,V.
(Producer),&Carter,T.
(Director).
(1986).
Undertheinfluence[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:CBSEntertainmentProductions.
Haft,S.
,Witt,P.
J.
,Thomas,T.
(Producers),&Weir,P.
(Director).
(1989).
Deadpoetssociety[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:BuenaVista.
Hesley,J.
W.
,&Hesley,J.
G.
(1998).
Renttwofilmsandlet'stalkinthemorning:Usingpopularmoviesinpsychotherapy.
NewYork:Wiley.
Hesley,J.
W.
,&Hesley,J.
G.
(2001).
Renttwofilmsandlet'stalkinthemorning:Usingpopularmoviesinpsychotherapy(2nded.
).
NewYork:Wiley.
Heston,M.
L.
,&Kottman,T.
(1997).
Moviesasmetaphors:Acounselingintervention.
JournalofHumanisticEducationandDevelopment,36,92–99.
Jaffe,R.
C.
(Producer),&Benton,R.
(Director).
(1979).
Kramervs.
Kramer[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ColumbiaPictures.
Jaffe,S.
R.
,Lansing,S.
(Producers),&Kaplan,J.
(Director).
(1988).
Theaccused[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ParamountPictures.
Karsch,A.
(Producer),&Streisand,B.
(Producer/Director).
(1991).
Princeoftides[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ColumbiaPictures.
Kasdan,L.
(Producer/Director).
(1983).
Thebigchill[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ColumbiaPictures.
Kazantzis,N.
,&Deane,F.
P.
(1999).
Psychologists'useofhomeworkassignmentsinclinicalpractice.
ProfessionalPsychology:ResearchandPractice,30,581–585.
Kazantzis,N.
,Deane,F.
P.
,Ronan,K.
R.
,&L'Abate,L.
(Eds.
).
(inpress).
Usinghomeworkassignmentsincognitive–behaviortherapy.
NewYork:Brunner-Routledge.
Kazantzis,N.
,&Lampropoulos,G.
K.
(Eds.
).
(2002).
Usinghomeworkassignmentsinpsychotherapy[Specialissue].
JournalofClinicalPsy-chology,58,487–585.
Kennedy,K.
,Marshall,F.
,Spielberg,S.
(Producers),&Goldberg,G.
D.
(Director).
(1989).
Dad[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:UniversalPictures.
Kerner,J.
,Avnet,J.
(Producers),&Mandoki,L.
(Director).
(1994).
Whenamanlovesawoman[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:BuenaVista.
L'Abate,L.
(2004).
Aguidetoself-helpworkbooksformentalhealthcliniciansandresearchers.
NewYork:Haworth.
Lambert,M.
J.
,Whipple,J.
L.
,Hawkins,E.
J.
,Vermeersch,D.
A.
,Nielsen,S.
L.
,&Smart,D.
W.
(2003).
IsittimeforclinicianstoroutinelytrackpatientoutcomeAmeta-analysis.
ClinicalPsychology:ScienceandPractice,10,288–301.
Lampropoulos,G.
K.
,Goldfried,M.
R.
,Castonguay,L.
G.
,Lambert,M.
J.
,Stiles,W.
B.
,&Nestoros,J.
N.
(2002).
WhatkindofresearchcanwerealisticallyexpectfromthepractitionerJournalofClinicalPsychol-ogy,58,1241–1264.
Lowry,H.
(Producer),&Rubin,B.
J.
(Producer/Director).
(1993).
Mylife[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ColumbiaPictures.
Marrs,R.
W.
(1995).
Ameta-analysisofbibliotherapystudies.
AmericanJournalofCommunityPsychology,23,843–870.
Marx,J.
A.
,Royalty,G.
M.
,Gyorky,Z.
K.
,&Stern,T.
E.
(1992).
Useofself-helpbooksinpsychotherapy.
ProfessionalPsychology:ResearchandPractice,23,300–305.
Mulvehill,C.
B.
(Producer),&Hackford,T.
(Producer/Director).
(1995).
DoloresClaiborne[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ColumbiaPictures.
Norcross,J.
C.
(2000).
Herecomestheself-helprevolutioninmentalhealth.
Psychotherapy,37,370–377.
Norcross,J.
C.
(2003,August).
Integratingself-helpintopsychotherapy:Revolutioninmentalhealthpractice.
APFRosalleeWeisslecturepre-sentedatthe111thAnnualConventionoftheAmericanPsychologicalAssociation,Toronto,Ontario,Canada.
Norcross,J.
C.
,Alford,B.
A.
,&DeMichele,J.
T.
(1992).
Thefutureofpsychotherapy:Delphidataandconcludingobservations.
Psychother-apy,29,150–158.
Norcross,J.
C.
,Hedges,M.
,&Prochaska,J.
O.
(2002).
Thefaceof2010:540LAMPROPOULOS,KAZANTZIS,ANDDEANEADelphipollonthefutureofpsychotherapy.
ProfessionalPsychology:ResearchandPractice,33,316–322.
Norcross,J.
C.
,Karg,R.
S.
,&Prochaska,J.
O.
(1997).
Clinicalpsychol-ogistsinthe1990s:PartI.
TheClinicalPsychologist,50(2),4–9.
Norcross,J.
C.
,Santrock,J.
W.
,Campbell,L.
F.
,Smith,T.
P.
,Sommer,R.
,&Zuckerman,E.
L.
(2000).
Authoritativeguidetoself-helpresourcesinmentalhealth.
NewYork:Guilford.
Norcross,J.
C.
,Santrock,J.
W.
,Campbell,L.
F.
,Smith,T.
P.
,Sommer,R.
,&Zuckerman,E.
L.
(2003).
Authoritativeguidetoself-helpresourcesinmentalhealth(Rev.
ed.
).
NewYork:Guilford.
Paden-Levy,D.
(2000).
Findinglogotherapyintoday'spopularculture.
InternationalForumforLogotherapy,23,95–100.
Pilsbury,S.
,Sanford,M.
(Producers),&Moorhouse,J.
(Director).
(1995).
HowtomakeanAmericanquilt[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:Uni-versalPictures.
Pratt,C.
A.
(Producer),&Carlino,L.
J.
(Director).
(1979).
ThegreatSantini[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:OrionPictures/WarnerBrothers.
Prochaska,J.
O.
,&DiClemente,C.
C.
(1992).
Thetranstheoreticalap-proach.
InJ.
C.
Norcross&M.
R.
Goldfried(Eds.
),Handbookofpsychotherapyintegration(pp.
300–334).
NewYork:BasicBooks.
Rubin,R.
J.
(Ed.
).
(1978a).
Bibliotherapysourcebook.
Phoenix,AZ:OryxPress.
Rubin,R.
J.
(1978b).
Usingbibliotherapy;Aguidetotheoryandpractice.
Phoenix,AZ:OryxPress.
Santrock,J.
W.
,Minnett,A.
M.
,&Campbell,B.
D.
(1994).
Theauthor-itativeguidetoself-helpbooks.
NewYork:Guilford.
Saxon,E.
(Producer),&Demme,J.
(Producer/Director).
(1993).
Philadel-phia[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:Tri-StarPictures.
Schulenberg,S.
E.
(2003).
Psychotherapyandmovies:Onusingfilmsinclinicalpractice.
JournalofContemporaryPsychotherapy,33,35–48.
Schwary,R.
L.
(Producer),&Redford,R.
(Director).
(1980).
Ordinarypeople[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:ParamountPictures.
Scogin,F.
R.
(Ed.
).
(2003a).
Integratingself-helpintopsychotherapy[Specialissue].
JournalofClinicalPsychology,59(2).
Scogin,F.
R.
(Ed.
).
(2003b).
Thestatusofself-administeredtreatments[Specialsection].
JournalofClinicalPsychology,59,247–349.
Scogin,F.
,Bynum,J.
,Stephens,G.
,&Calhoon,S.
(1990).
Efficacyofself-administeredtreatmentprograms:Meta-analyticreview.
Profes-sionalPsychology:ResearchandPractice,21,42–47.
Sharp,C.
,Smith,J.
V.
,&Cole,A.
(2002).
Cinematherapy:Metaphoricallypromotingtherapeuticchange.
CounsellingPsychologyQuarterly,15,269–276.
Solomon,G.
(1995).
Themotionpictureprescription.
SantaRosa,CA:Aslan.
Solomon,G.
(2001).
Reeltherapy:Howmoviesinspireyoutoovercomelife'sproblems.
NewYork:Lebhar-FriedmanBooks.
Stark,R.
(Producer),&Ross,H.
(Director).
(1989).
Steelmagnolias[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:Tri-StarPictures.
Starker,S.
(1988).
Psychologistsandself-helpbooks:Attitudesandpre-scriptivepracticesofclinicians.
AmericanJournalofPsychotherapy,42,448–455.
Vanwagenen,S.
,Forte,H.
(Producers),&Masterson,P.
(Director).
(1985).
TriptoBountiful[Motionpicture].
UnitedStates:IslandPictures.
Wedding,D.
,&Niemiec,R.
M.
(2003).
Theclinicaluseoffilmsinpsychotherapy.
JournalofClinicalPsychology,59,207–215.
ReceivedJuly28,2003RevisionreceivedOctober24,2003AcceptedJanuary28,2004Ⅲ541PSYCHOLOGISTS'USEOFMOTIONPICTURES

妮妮云36元,美国VPS洛杉矶 8核 8G 36元/月,香港葵湾 8核 8G

妮妮云的来历妮妮云是 789 陈总 张总 三方共同投资建立的网站 本着“良心 便宜 稳定”的初衷 为小白用户避免被坑妮妮云的市场定位妮妮云主要代理市场稳定速度的云服务器产品,避免新手购买云服务器的时候众多商家不知道如何选择,妮妮云就帮你选择好了产品,无需承担购买风险,不用担心出现被跑路 被诈骗的情况。妮妮云的售后保证妮妮云退款 通过于合作商的友好协商,云服务器提供2天内全额退款,超过2天不退款 物...

HostKvm香港VPS七折:$5.95/月KVM-2GB内存/40GB硬盘/500GB月流量

HostKvm是一家成立于2013年的国外主机服务商,主要提供VPS主机,基于KVM架构,可选数据中心包括日本、新加坡、韩国、美国、俄罗斯、中国香港等多个地区机房,均为国内直连或优化线路,延迟较低,适合建站或者远程办公等。商家本月针对香港国际机房提供特别7折优惠码,其他机房全场8折,优惠后2G内存香港VPS每月5.95美元起,支持使用PayPal或者支付宝付款。下面以香港国际(HKGlobal)为...

2021HawkHost老鹰主机黑色星期五虚拟主机低至3.5折 永久4.5折

老鹰主机HawkHost是个人比较喜欢的海外主机商,如果没有记错的话,大约2012年左右的时候算是比较早提供支付宝付款的主机商。当然这个主机商成立时间更早一些的,由于早期提供支付宝付款后,所以受众用户比较青睐,要知道我们早期购买海外主机是比较麻烦的,信用卡和PAYPAL还没有普及,大家可能只有银联和支付宝,很多人选择海外主机还需要代购。虽然如今很多人建站少了,而且大部分人都用云服务器。但是老鹰主机...

byebyelove为你推荐
免费com域名注册有没有完全免费的域名?免费域名空间哪个免费空间的域名最好网站空间购买怎么购买一个网站空间及购买注意事项asp网站空间谁有能申请免费的ASP空间网站?100m网站空间100M网站空间可以存多少张图片和多少文字?香港虚拟主机香港虚拟主机多少钱一年呢?便宜虚拟主机哪里有国内便宜虚拟主机mysql虚拟主机如何建立支持PHP+MySQL的虚拟主机?安徽虚拟主机华夏网络科技有限公司的介绍域名解析什么是域名解析?它有什么作用?
万网域名注册 西安域名注册 哈尔滨服务器租用 l5520 wordpress技巧 xfce evssl xen 嘟牛 河南移动邮件系统 卡巴斯基破解版 架设邮件服务器 沈阳主机托管 监控服务器 学生服务器 1美元 免备案cdn加速 阿里云个人邮箱 websitepanel so域名 更多