EOI_INDUCEDivybridge

ivybridge  时间:2021-03-28  阅读:()
MessagePassingWorkloadsinKVMDavidMatlack,dmatlack@google.
com1MessagePassingWorkloadsLoopbackTCP_RRIPIandHLTDISCLAIMER:x86andIntelVT-xHaltPollingInterruptsandquestionsarewelcome!
Overview2Usually,anythingthatfrequentlyswitchesbetweenrunningandidle.
Event-drivenworkloadsMemcacheLAMPserversRedisMultithreadedworkloadsusinglowlatencywait/signalprimitivesforcoordination.
WindowsEventObjectspthread_cond_wait/pthread_cond_signalInter-processcommunicationTCP_RR(benchmark)MessagePassingWorkloads3Intuition:Workloadswhichdon'tinvolveIOvirtualizationshouldrunatnearnativeperformance.
Reality:MessagePassingWorkloadsmaynotinvolveanyIObutwillstillperformnXworsethannative.
(loopback)Memcache:2xhigherlatency.
WindowsEventObjects:3-4xhigherlatency.
MessagePassingWorkloads4MessagePassingWorkloads2.
Receive1bytefromclient.
Send1byteback.
1.
Send1bytetoserver.
3.
Receive1bytefromserver.
Microbenchmark:LoopbackTCP_RRClientandServerping-pong1-byteofdataoveranestablishedTCPconnection.
Loopback:Nonetworkingdevices(realorvirtual)involved.
Performance:Latencyofeachtransaction.
Onetransaction:(idle)(idle)(idle)ClientServer5LoopbackTCP_RRPerformance6Host:IvyBridge3.
11KernelGuest:DebianWheezyBackports(3.
16Kernel)3xhigherlatency25usslowerMessagePassingon1CPUContextSwitchMessagePassingon>1CPUInterprocessor-InterruptsWhat'sgoingonunderthehoodVMEXITsareagoodplacetostartlooking.
KVMhasbuilt-inVMEXITcountersandtimers.
perf-kvm(1)VirtualOverheadsofTCP_RR7VirtualOverheadsofTCP_RRTotalNumberofVMEXITsVMEXITs/Transaction1VCPU2VCPU1VCPU2VCPUEXTERNAL_INTERRUPT16705123710.
020.
07MSR_WRITE259917043340.
009.
58IO_INSTRUCTION17867620.
000.
00EOI_INDUCED613250.
000.
00EXCEPTION_NMI289310.
000.
00CPUID2521120.
000.
00CR_ACCESS1712720.
000.
00HLT343543930.
001.
99EPT_VIOLATION200.
000.
00PAUSE_INSTRUCTION020140.
000.
012HLTperTransaction10MSR_WRITEperTransaction8HLTsofTCP_RR2HLTCPUinstruction.
StopexecutinginstructionsonthisCPUuntilaninterruptarrives.
VCPUwishestostopexecutinginstructions.
GuestOShasdecidedthatthereisnothingtodo.
Nothingtodo==idle.
Messagepassingworkloadsswitchbetweenrunningandidle.
.
.
910MSR_WRITE"WritetoModelSpecificRegister"instructionexecutedintheguest.
8APICTimer"InitialCount"Register(MSR838)Writtentostartaper-CPUtimer.
"Startcountingdownandfireaninterruptwhenyougettozero.
"ArtifactofNOHZguestkernel.
2APICInterruptCommandRegister(MSR830)Usedtosendinterprocessor-interrupts(IPI).
Usedtodeliver"messages"betweenclient/serverprocessesrunningonseparateCPUs.
MSR_WRITEsofTCP_RR10VMEXITsofTCP_RRVMEXITSAPICTimerRegisterAPICInterruptCommandRegister(IPI)HLTclientclientidleserveridleidle1.
Send1bytetoserver.
Waitforresponse.
2.
Receive1bytefromclient.
Send1byteback.
3.
Receive1bytefromserver.
VCPU0VCPU111HLTHLTHLTIPIIPIAPICTIMERAPICTIMERAPICTIMERAPICTIMERVMEXITsofTCP_RRVMEXITSAPICTimerRegisterAPICInterruptCommandRegister(IPI)HLTclientclientidleserveridleidle1.
Send1bytetoserver.
Waitforresponse.
2.
Receive1bytefromclient.
Send1byteback.
3.
Receive1bytefromserver.
VCPU0VCPU112HLTHLTHLTIPIIPIAPICTIMERAPICTIMERAPICTIMERAPICTIMERCriticalPath8pertransaction4onthecriticalpathNOHZ(ticklessguestkernel)"Disable"scheduler-tickuponenteringidle.
"Enable"scheduler-tickuponleavingidle.
scheduler-tick==APICTimer(couldalsobeTSCDeadlineTimer)Why2writespertransitioninto/outofidlehrtimer_cancelhrtimer_startAdds3-5ustoround-triplatency.
APICTimer"InitialCount"Register13HLT:x86Instruction.
CPUstopsexecutinginstructionsuntilaninterruptarrives.
ThispartofHLTisnotonthecriticalpath!
HowitworksinKVMPlaceVCPUthreadonawaitqueue.
YieldtheCPUtoanotherthread.
HLTkvm_vcpu_block->schedule()VMEXITHLTcontextswitchtoanotherusertask,kernelthread,oridleVCPU(guest)PCPU(KVM)14kvm_sched_outSendinganIPItowakeupaHLT-edCPU.
Onthecriticalpath!
IPI+HLTWRMSR:APICInterruptCommandRegisterkvm_vcpu_kickreturnfromschedule()inkvm_vcpu_block()vmx_vcpu_runIPIISRVMEXITVMRESUMEVCPU1VCPU0(HLT-ed)guesthostkvm_sched_in*VMEXITandVMRESUMEimplementedinHardware.
time15SendinganIPItowakeupaHLT-edCPU.
Onthecriticalpath!
Sameoperationonbaremetalisentirelyimplementedinhardware.
HowmuchoverheadfromvirtualizationUnlikeAPIC_TMICT,can'tjusttimeVMEXITs.
Wecancomparewiththesameoperationonphysicalhardware.
IPI+HLT16KVMversusHardwareRing0Microbenchmark(kvm-unit-tests)1.
VCPU0:HLT.
2.
~100usdelay3.
VCPU1:A=RDTSC4.
VCPU1:SendIPIto[V]CPU0.
5.
VCPU0:B=RDTSC(firstinstructionofIPIISR).
6.
Latency=B-A7.
Repeat.
RuninKVMguestandonbare-metal.
Compare!
17VMRESUMEWRMSRkvm_vcpu_kickreturnfromschedule()inkvm_vcpu_block()vmx_vcpu_runIPIISRVMEXITVCPU1VCPU0(HLT-ed)guesthostkvm_sched_intimeKVMversusHardwareA=RDTSCB=RDTSC18Median:KVMis12xslowerPathologicalcase(witnessed):KVMis400xslowerBestcase(witnessed):KVMis11xslowerKVM:5.
7us;Hardware:0.
5usKVMversusHardwareCyclesKVMHardwareMin137001200Average15800120050%ile14900120090%ile16000130099%ile249001300Max5210001400Host:SandyBridge@2.
6GHz3.
11KernelKVMperformanceissimilaronIvyBridge(5.
6us)andHaswell(4.
9us).
19Notesaboutthisbenchmark:NoguestFPUtosave/restore.
Hostotherwiseidle(VCPUcontextswitchestoidleonHLT).
Hostpowermanagementnottheculprit.
KVMversusHardware20KVMHLTInternalsSoKVMisslowatdeliveringIPIsand/orcomingoutofHLT.
ButwhyPossibleculprits:WRMSRvmx_vcpu_runIPIISRVMEXITVMRESUMEVCPU1VCPU0(HLT-ed)kvm_sched_intimereturnfromschedule()inkvm_vcpu_block()kvm_vcpu_kick21VMRESUMEvmx_vcpu_runkvm_vcpu_kickKVMHLTInternalsSoKVMisslowatdeliveringIPIsand/orcomingoutofHLT.
ButwhyPossibleculprits:WRMSRIPIISRVMEXITVCPU1VCPU0(HLT-ed)kvm_sched_intimereturnfromschedule()inkvm_vcpu_block()22RDTSCRDTSCRDTSCRDTSCRDTSCKVMHLTInternalsWRMSRkvm_vcpu_kickreturnfromschedule()inkvm_vcpu_block()vmx_vcpu_runIPIISRVMEXITVMRESUMEMin(cycles):400600730032001300VCPU1VCPU0guesthostVT-xKVMSchedulerkvm_sched_in:4924001200850034001400Median(cycles):23Unsurprisingly,theschedulertakessometimetoruntheVCPUSlowevenintheuncontended,cache-hot,case.
ImagineiftheVCPUiscontendingforCPUtimewithotherthreads.
Experiment:Don'tscheduleonHLT.
JustpollfortheIPIinkvm_vcpu_block.
KVMHLTInternals24Whathappenswhenyoudon'tscheduleonHLTKVM(Alwaysschedule)5.
7usKVM(Neverschedule)1.
7usHardware(SandyBridge)0.
5usNeverschedule!
CyclesKVM(Alwaysschedule)KVM(Neverschedule)HardwareMin1380040001200Average158004400120050%ile149004300120090%ile160004500130099%ile2490069001300Max52100050000140025SimilarimprovementsonIvyBridge(5.
6us->1.
6us)Haswell(4.
9us->1.
5us).
Neverschedule!
WRMSRkvm_vcpu_kickreturnfromschedule()inkvm_vcpu_block()vmx_vcpu_runIPIISRVMEXITVMRESUMEAlwaysschedule:4001200850034001400VCPU1VCPU0guesthostVT-xKVMSchedulerNeverschedule:300130011004001200(mediancycles)26Neverschedule!
WeeliminatealmostallofthelatencyoverheadbynotschedulingonHLT.
Schedulingisoftentherightthingtodo.
LetotherthreadsrunorsavehostCPUpower.
Mostofthetimeimprovesguestperformance(lettheIOthreadsrun!
).
Canhurtperformance.
Seemicrobenchmark.
SeeTCP_RR.
27Halt-PollingStep1:PollForuptoXnanoseconds:IfataskiswaitingtorunonourCPU,gotoStep2.
Checkifaguestinterruptarrived.
Ifso,wearedone.
Repeat.
Step2:schedule()Scheduleoutuntilit'stimetocomeoutofHLT.
Pros:WorksonshortHLTs(Cons:IncreasesCPUusage(~1%foridleVCPUsifX=200,000ns)Doesnotappeartonegativelyaffectturboofactivecores.
28Halt-PollingMemcache:1.
5xlatencyimprovementWindowsEventObjects:2xlatencyimprovementReducemessagepassinglatencyby10-15us(includingnetworklatency).
29Halt-PollingMergedintothe4.
0kernel[PATCH]kvm:addhalt_poll_nsmoduleparameterThankstoPaoloBonziniUsetheKVMmoduleparameterhalt_poll_nstocontrolhowlongtopolloneachHLT.
Futureimprovements:Automaticpolltoggling(removeidleCPUoverheadbyturningpollingoff).
Automatichalt_poll_nsKVMwillset(andvary)halt_poll_nsdynamically.
Howtodothisisanopenquestion.
.
.
ideasLazyContextSwitchingEquivalentfeature,butavailableforanykernelcomponenttouse.
30ConclusionMessagePassingEvenloopbackmessagepassingrequiresvirtualization.
Beingidle(asaLinuxguest)requiresvirtualization.
Cross-CPUcommunicationrequiresvirtualization.
Halt-Pollingsaves10-15usonmessagepassinground-triplatency.
Remaininground-triplatency:4MSRwritestotheAPICtimer(3-5us)IPIsend(~2us)HLTwakeup(evenwithhalt-polling,stilladds~3us!
)31

RAKsmart 年中活动 独立服务器限时$30秒杀 VPS主机低至$1.99

RAKsmart 虽然是美国主机商,但是商家的主要客户群还是在我们国内,于是我们可以看到每次的国内节日促销活动期间商家也会发布促销。包括这次年中大促活动,RAKsmart商家也有发布为期两个月的年终活动,其中有商家擅长的独立服务器和便宜VPS主机。服务器包括站群服务器、特价服务器、高达10G带宽不限制流量的美国服务器。商家优惠活动,可以看到对应商品的优惠,同时也可以使用 优惠码 RAKBL9 同时...

两款半月湾 HMBcloud 春节88折日本和美国CN2 VPS主机套餐

春节期间我们很多朋友都在忙着吃好喝好,当然有时候也会偶然的上网看看。对于我们站长用户来说,基本上需要等到初八之后才会开工,现在有空就看看是否有商家的促销。这里看到来自HMBcloud半月湾服务商有提供两款春节机房方案的VPS主机88折促销活动,分别是来自洛杉矶CN2 GIA和日本CN2的方案。八八折优惠码:CNY-GIA第一、洛杉矶CN2 GIA美国原生IP地址、72小时退款保障、三网回程CN2 ...

Hosteons:新上1Gbps带宽KVM主机$21/年起,AMD Ryzen CPU+NVMe高性能主机$24/年起_韩国便宜服务器

我们在去年12月分享过Hosteons新上AMD Ryzen9 3900X CPU及DDR4内存、NVMe硬盘的高性能VPS产品的消息,目前商家再次发布了产品更新信息,暂停新开100M带宽KVM套餐,新订单转而升级为新的Budget KVM VPS(SSD)系列,带宽为1Gbps端口,且配置大幅升级,目前100M带宽仅保留OpenVZ架构产品可新订购,所有原有主机不变,用户一直续费一直可用。Bud...

ivybridge为你推荐
怎么查询商标如何查询商标注册安徽汽车网安徽什么汽车网站比较好?access数据库Access数据库对象的操作包括哪五种?原代码什么是原代码月神谭适合12岁男孩的网名,要非主流的,帮吗找找,谢啦同一ip网站同一个IP不同的30个网站,是不是在一个服务器上呢?www.765.com哪里有免费的电影网站杨丽晓博客杨丽晓今年高考了吗?汴京清谈汴京还被称为什么?月风随笔散文校园月色600字初中作文
日本vps bbr diahosting 流媒体服务器 php主机 发包服务器 dd444 免费个人空间申请 空间合租 33456 如何注册阿里云邮箱 web服务器是什么 登陆空间 上海电信测速 中国电信网络测速 东莞服务器托管 百度云空间 美国迈阿密 重庆联通服务器托管 腾讯云平台 更多